10/06/2026
Here's the full lowdown from the surf world on surfEXPLORE — and it's a genuinely mixed picture, with passionate voices on both sides.
The Book Itself
The book is divided into 28 chapters, each detailing a separate location and surfEXPLORE mission, covering a broad geographical palette arranged alphabetically, ranging from Algeria to Haiti, Western Sahara to the Philippines. Each chapter follows a set template — a brief history of the location, the struggles involved in travelling there (mostly dealing with government officials and paperwork), and details on the surf spots and surfing done on the trip.
Production Quality: Solid
On the production side, the book looks very good — top-shelf print quality, no misspellings across 56,000 words, no mangled captions. Everyone at Schiffer did a great job.
Reader Enthusiasm: Strong
Fans on Amazon UK have been vocal. One reader called it "full of amazing stories of discovery" with photos that are "original and of top quality," saying it should be in any serious travel-oriented surfer's collection. Another described it as the best coffee table book/conversation piece they'd had in years — and ordered a second copy for Christmas.
Critical Reception: More Complicated
Swellnet's in-depth review by Steve Shearer was more measured. While Callahan is described as competent at composing a sentence, the reviewer found his prose utilitarian — conveying information but lacking spark, originality, and emotion. That sense of crushing boredom, despair, anticipation, and soaring bliss known to surfers who have searched off the beaten track for waves is largely absent.
The Big Controversy: Ethics of Spot Exposure
This is where things get heated. A large chunk of the potential readership sees the book as morally compromised — an illegitimate exercise in "neo-colonialism" and exploitation. They view remaining secret spots as sacrosanct and requiring protection from commercialism. Callahan rejects this, arguing that surf tourism brings economic benefit to local communities and should be encouraged, even if secret spots get blown out.
The book has thrown the door wide open to a surf world full of influencers looking to commodify spots — and the reviewer notes we live in the era of digital commodification of everything.
Amazon Rankings
On Amazon US, the hardcover currently sits at #87 in Surfing books — a respectable niche position for a specialised title. Amazon
Bottom line: The surf community is split. Travel-hungry surfers and coffee table book lovers are enthusiastic. Core surf purists and critics argue it trades depth for breadth and raises uncomfortable ethical questions about blowing up secret spots. As its author, you should know the conversation is lively and ongoing — which itself drives visibility.
. Readers embark on a global journey of discovery with , an unparalleled exploration of 28 extraordinary and untapped surfing destinations. Join internationally recognized surf travel expert John Seaton Callahan and the surfEXPLORE Group as they unveil breathtaking waves, vibrant cultures,...