02/27/2026
Come along with us for a rare little brunch date at Medium Rare 🥩✨
They advertise it as “unlimited steak and fries,” and baby… you know we ran, not walked. As self-proclaimed steak connoisseurs who have beef with mediocre cuts, our expectations were sky-high.
So imagine our surprise when the “steak” strutted out looking a little… thin. It turns out, it’s sliced London broil — not exactly the prime time cut we were hoping for. However, the secret peppercorn sauce was to die for!! And listen, if you can’t tell your ribeye from your rump, you might be totally fine. But for us? It just didn’t meat the moment. (See what i did there?)
And let’s talk about this “unlimited” situation. It’s not endless steak and fries … you get two servings per person. That’s not unlimited… that’s a sequel.
If you go the brunch route ($39.95), it’s unlimited drinks (okay, we see you 👀) but only one serving of steak and fries. So the mimosas keep flowing, but the beef? One and done.
Now don’t get us wrong, for NYC, it’s still not a bad deal. The vibes are cute, the concept is fun, and if you’re not super pressed about premium cuts, you probably won’t have a cow.
For us though? Let’s just say the experience was a little… under-seasoned. We came hungry for greatness and left feeling medium about Medium Rare. 🥩
