12/01/2024
The Dark Read gothic twist to A Christmas Carol is the best-selling collection during the holiday season. But of all the many adaptations of Dickens' beloved novel, which is the best?
The first film version of Dickens' story, Scrooge, or Marley's Ghost, was made in Brighton, England, in 1901 by RW Paul and Walter Booth; since then, the story has been adapted close to 40 times for the big screen and around 50 times for TV. In all these different interpretations, the most effective performance by far is that of the great Scottish actor Alastair Sim (1900–76) in producer George Minter's 1951 version.
Directed by Brian Desmond-Hurst, whose first film was the 1934 Poe adaption A Tell-Tale Heart (aka A Bucket of Blood), the film was a massive hit in Britain but considered too horrific and adult for the US market. It was turned down for a premiere at Radio City Music Hall and—like that other Christmas classic, It's a Wonderful Life—failed to find an audience until it was broadcast on PBS in the 1970s.
The film is improved immeasurably by Cyril Pennington-Richards' excellent cinematography (he also lensed the 1956 version of 1984) and a literate, inventive script by Noel Langley (The Wizard of Oz). But this is Sim's show; his Scrooge is utterly believable in the miserly bitterness of the early scenes—there's an underlying anger and disgust to his interactions with people, and he disdains them all regardless of class—his terror at the glimpse of his fate and, most importantly, the unbridled joy of his awakening. No one, human or animated, before or since, has pulled off the transformation so convincingly.
It helps that Sim is supported by cameos and early performances from some of Britain's finest character actors: Ernest Thesiger (The Bride of Frankenstein), Mervyn Johns (Dead of Night), Carol Marsh (Hammer's Horror of Dracula), George Cole (Sim's protege and future UK TV Star), Miles Malleson (The Brides of Dracula), and Patrick Macnee (Steed in the iconic TV series, The Avengers). The film was edited by Clive Donner, who went on to direct the George C Scott TV version in 1984.
Dark Read's Christmas Carol collection (including the best-selling jigsaw puzzle) can be viewed here: https://www.etsy.com/shop/DarkReadStudio?section_id=45698685