03/06/2025
Northanger Abbey is actually my favourite Austen novel. If I had to leave one behind in a fire, it'd be Emma; her character arc is minimal and she's insufferable all the way through. As we celebrate 250 years since Jane Austen's birth, do you agree with The New Yorker and which is your least favourite Austen? 🙃
“Northanger Abbey” is the least beloved of Jane Austen’s six novels. It is also one of the most frequently assigned in university-level literature classes. These two things are related. For one thing, it is very much a novel about novels, deriving much of its energy and humor from mocking the tropes of the sentimental novel of the 18th century—particularly the convention of endowing protagonists with extraordinary personal qualities and heartrending histories. The novel’s heroine, Catherine Morland, is an ordinary middle-class English girl whose love for books is one of her most striking qualities. The ones she prefers are “all story and no reflection,” from which “nothing like useful knowledge can be gained.” Despite its somewhat broad satire of the effect of novel-reading on a mind like Catherine’s, “Northanger” is no churlish attack on the novel. It’s not even an attack on the gothic novel. “It is rather a rebuttal to such critiques, albeit one so elegant, and so conversant in the various arguments against the novel and its readers, that its radicalness has often passed unnoticed,” Adelle Waldman writes.
With so much in the book’s favor—a style that is trademark Austen, an appealing and ingenuous heroine, an equally appealing love interest, and an abundance of sly commentary on “the Novel” that ought to appeal to the kind of people who love Austen, i.e., to novel readers—why is “Northanger” not more appreciated? Read why Waldman finds the book “irresistible": https://newyorkermag.visitlink.me/eWIy2Z