My Sister & Me

My Sister & Me Vintage Goods and Gifts for Sale
Antiques, collectibles, vintage and new vintage inspired items including glass, jewelry, home goods/decor and clocks!

My Sister & Me

Whether you like classic or new urban vintage, My Sister & Me is sure to have the unique goods and gifts you'll love to accessorize you and your home. Across the street from the Lake Geneva Public Library, you'll find us in our restored 1862 Italianate home in the Maple Park Historical District. Owned and operated by twin sisters Janie and Jeannie, be sure to stop by and see us. We would love to help you find that perfect gift, or something special just for you.

01/17/2026

So sorry, the repair work is taking longer than expected. We hope to be open on Monday the 19th. Hope to see you soon.

Janie and Jeannie

01/12/2026

We will be closed Jan 12 through Jan 16 to have the walls repaired in the store because of water damage. We hope to be open again on Saturday the 17th. Check back with us for more updates as they become available. See you soon!

Jeannie and Janie

Christmas! Collectibles and more!
12/05/2025

Christmas! Collectibles and more!

Happy 12th Anniversary at My Sister and Me LLC. 911 Main Street, Lake Geneva, WI. Open six days. Closed Wednesdays.
10/05/2025

Happy 12th Anniversary at My Sister and Me LLC.
911 Main Street, Lake Geneva, WI. Open six days. Closed Wednesdays.

08/30/2025

In stock now-Halloween!

06/06/2025

Jeannie and I want to share why our store has been closed so much lately.

My brother-in-law Joel, Jeannie's husband, has bravely fought and lost his battle with cancer.

We appreciate your patience as we navigate the days ahead with faith and resilience.

For now, we will be open Saturdays through Tuesdays and look forward to returning to our regular hours very soon.

Thank you to our amazing customers. We're grateful for your support.

Janie and Jeannie

05/31/2025

So sorry, we will be closed today, Saturday May 31st. :(

05/26/2025

We are open today!
10:30-5:00

01/30/2025

Winter Fest Sale Items
Big sale at My Sister and Me !
20% OFF:
Christmas ornaments and decor
Antique Clocks
Stained Glass Windows
Large selections
Happy Winter!

12/31/2024

Happy New Year!

Hand carved carousel horse from Philadelphia. Inquire within.
12/21/2024

Hand carved carousel horse from Philadelphia.
Inquire within.

12/21/2024

Hi,
Merry Christmas to all! Happy Holidays!
Reminder that we will be closed:
Christmas Eve
Christmas Day
New Years Eve
New Year’s Day
And as always closed on Wednesday’s
Hope to see you soon!

Address

911 W Main Street
Lake Geneva, WI
53147

Opening Hours

Monday 10:30am - 6pm
Tuesday 10:30am - 6pm
Thursday 10:30am - 6pm
Friday 10:30am - 6pm
Saturday 10:30am - 6pm
Sunday 10:30am - 6pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when My Sister & Me posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to My Sister & Me:

Shortcuts

Share

Category